Flight detour due to strikeBack to Forum
Tagged: ATC Strikes
The above is a screenshot of a flight from Birmingham to Palma (earlier this morning). It circumnavigated French airspace which resulted in a long detour. Many flights are following the same principle.
The industry body Airlines 4 Europe sent it over in illustration of the latest strike with at least 200 cancellations today during the latest Air Traffic Control (ATC) strike in France.
Control centres in Reims and Marseille have been on strike since Monday evening. The strike will continue until Wednesday morning.
There have been more than 250 strike days since 2004, the A4E group says.
A4E is calling on the French government to use its upcoming “Assises de la mobilité” (National Mobility Summit) on 19 September to identify new priorities in terms of mobility and transport and to consider measures capable of improving the predictability of strikes’ impact and decrease their damage to the French and European economy.
“In June, the European Commission published its Communication “Aviation: an Open and Connected Europe” in an effort to enhance airspace efficiency and connectivity. The Commission rightly encourages Member States and stakeholders, including social partners, to take action to improve service continuity in air traffic management. Political, operational and technological solutions exist for a problem that affects the whole continent. Limiting the impact of Air Traffic Management strikes on travellers and business, without questioning controllers’ fundamental right to strike, is a key objective of A4E.”
“Solutions A4E has called for encompass the compulsory minimum of 72 hours notification of participation in a strike, which should be implemented by European States where possible and practical, and an upper airspace evolution away from geographical dependency enabling European passengers to make uninterrupted journeys throughout the continent.”
“During the 2010-16 period, there were 217 ATC strike days in the EU – one disrupted day every nine days. In total, there were 278 disrupted days if you take into account the days before and after an ATC strike as flights had to be cancelled in advance and accumulated delays spilt over to the next day. Since 2010 the overall impact of ATC strikes have cost €12 billion to the EU economy, associated with more than 140,000 jobs.”12 Sep 2017
There are Strikes by Aena for many dates in September October November and December starting 22nd September. It relates to Malaga Airport but do not know of other Spanish Airports are affected.
Its starts on 22nd as they have postponed 17th September while the continue to talk so it is possible that the may postpone further.
I am flying BA into Malaga on 24th (one of the confirmed strike days) and asked them if I can switch to GIB but they say no at the moment.13 Sep 2017
Planned Strike dates
The 15th and 17th are cancelled
September: 15, 17, 22, 24 and 29
October; 1, 6, 11, 15, 27, 30 and 31
November: 3 and 5
December: 1, 4, 5, 7, 8, 10, 26, 27, 28, 29 and 3013 Sep 2017
This screen shot is very impressive.
However I really wonder who is responsible for this circumnavigation of French airspace yesterday morning.
The flight on the screenshot is Thomas Cook morning flight from BXH to PMI MT1248 which lasted almost one hour more than usual due to this circumnavigation. Interestingly Thomas Cook is not a member of Airline4Europe.
All 3 other flights from BHX to PMI on the same day were able to have the most direct route you can imagine between BXH and PMI which made it possible for them to land almost on time or ahead of schedule.
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/zb950#ed715dd departed 25mn after MT1248 and arrived 20minutes ahead of schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/zb956#ed55289 arrived 00:21 minutes ahead of schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/fr2162#ed5e76e arrivede 00:19 minutes behind schedule
About 20 fligts flew from London to Palma on the same day. One was cancelled. All others departed and all of them but two used the same very direct route. Can you imagine that both flights who were “obliged” to circumnvavigate French airspace were Thomas Cook flights ?
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/mt1352#ed3ebed 1 hour behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/mt1216#ed41377 2 hours behind schedule after a circumnavgiation of French airspace + another detour via Madrid for an unkwnown reason (probably another strike in Spain ?).
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/u22271#ed3e191 00h10 minutes behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/u27421#ed3f7c6 00:20 minutes ahead of schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/zb220#ed4011f 00:13 minutes behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/ls1529#ed42810 00:36 minutes behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/zb872#ece1ded 00:38 behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/u28621#ed45c73 1:41 behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/ba8485#ed448af 00:31 behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/zb224#ed4384d 00:08 ahead of schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/u28625#ed48cf8 00:02 behind schedule
https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/fr8386#ed4b5dd 00:18 ahead of schedule
Most of other flight from UK airport didn’t have to circumnavigate French Airspace nor did they were late.
Another interesting information is that more than 50% of the flights which were cancelled on monday (110/200) were flights operated by Ryanair which seems to suffer a lack of pilots …
What is right, what is wrong, what is strategy in all this ???13 Sep 2017
HKTbound, the strikes have been postponed until the end of October given the meetings between government and unions had initially gone well. If there is no agreement before the end of October the strikes will be reinstated albeit the unions have to give 10 days notice of starting a strike14 Sep 2017
More strikes today….
Press release from Airlines For Europe (A4E)
At least 1,000 flight cancellations and heavy delays may be the result of the latest ATC strike in Europe. In particular, control centres at airports in Paris (Charles de Gaulle & Orly), Beauvais, Lyon, Nice, Marseille, Toulouse, Bordeaux and Nantes have been on strike since Monday evening. The Direction Générale de l’Aviation Civile (DGAC) requested airlines to reduce their flight offerings in France by 30%, but also services overflying France will be affected. The strike will continue until Wednesday morning.
“The impact of the seventh strike day in France this year will be quite significant: airlines have been forced to reduce their flight programme by a third. We expect to see escalating delays throughout the day, forcing airlines to cut back on their flight programme even further. Given France’s its geographical location, ATC strikes in France and the reduction of capacity in French airspace considerably penalises passengers throughout the continent,” said Thomas Reynaert, Managing Director of A4E.
Studies for the European Commission (Ricardo & York Aviation, 2016) and for A4E (PwC, 2016) revealed that seven out of ten European ATC strikes since 2005 have taken place in France. During the same period France accounted for 252 strike days while 15 other EU countries have not experienced any ATC strike at all.
“Two-thirds of all European ATC strike days are taking place in France – French controllers are on strike 24 days, annually. The European economy, its tourism and trade sectors pay a high price for French ATC strikes, namely EUR 1.4 billion per year. We have no intention to question the fundamental right of workers to defend their interest, but we call on the French government to improve the situation. Solutions such as a compulsory 72 hours individual notification of participation in a strike, the protection of overflights while not at expense of the country where the strike originates, or an improved continuity of service have been identified. The French authorities now need to take action,” added Reynaert.
A4E also calls for a better social dialogue and an upper airspace evolution away from geographical dependency enabling European passengers to make uninterrupted journeys throughout the continent.
On 8 June 2017, the European Commission adopted a Communication which notably encourages EU governments and stakeholders to apply practices with a view to improving service continuity in air traffic management. These include the promotion of an efficient social dialogue, the provision of individual notification of participation to industrial action and the preservation of overflights. Since 2010 ATC strikes have cost €12 billion to the EU economy, associated with more than 140,000 jobs.10 Oct 2017
Why is it that the damn French are allowed, time and time again, to mess up the plans and hopes of tens of thousands of people with these strikes?
Does no French leader have the spine to stand up to the unions and destroy them, or are they always going to wave the white flag?10 Oct 2017