New Champagne in Club Europe

Back to Forum
Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)

  • Anonymous
    Guest

    FDOS_UK
    Participant

    http://www.airlive.net/2016/01/news-british-airways-to-serve-champagne.html

    In a blind test, 8/10 testers preferred Castlenau NV to meths and Saudi Champagne 🙂


    dutchyankee
    Participant

    This is the same Champagne that Lufthansa serves in Long Haul Business Class to the USA. Not bad at all, although I was and still am a fan of the Pommery BA used to serve in CE.


    FDOS_UK
    Participant

    Have LH changed? Last few times I flew with them, it was Jacquard Brut Mosaique, which is fine by me.


    dutchyankee
    Participant

    Not sure if they have changed as I have only just switched my Long Haul travel to Lufthansa, but on my flights in late December and early January this was the Champagne in the menu/served (and thankfully they had plenty loaded as Champagne is what I love to drink on board).


    icenspice
    Participant

    Poohaps a resident oenophile will give his/her verdict on Castelnau Brut, served on my last LH Business longhaul in October.


    esselle
    Participant

    I think that any champagne, served in a miniature bottle, with a plastic screw cap, as these are, is going to be just an amalgam of average frankly, because the wine is not made to be packaged this way, and is only ever done so for airlines use.

    Cold, fizzy wine, and nothing wrong with that, but don’t get too excited.


    SGJNI1961
    Participant

    @icenspice

    While I don’t have any objective qualification apart from actual taste….. its SH1T! I really can’t stand the stuff. I had words with the staff in the “First” lounge some weeks ago when it was all that was available, I wasn’t the only one. I have actually been wondering for some months if its all too regular appearance in the lounges wasn’t a quiet campaign to adjust us into accepting the awful stuff. Once they withdraw the Tatt from the lounge, I’m gone to the competition. I can live with the crap (but perhaps improving) food, the hit and miss crews and the ancient 747’s but, serve me that instead of the Taittinger and it’s a firm “Non” from me.
    My next 8 flights are not on BA quite deliberately, I wanted to widen my experience with a view to leaving BA and/or Oneworld. The bloody bubbly was one of the last things in BA’s favour (yes, I’m that easily pleased), but really, does anyone in BA ever fly on the competition???? Ever?
    I gave a Golden Ticket on Dec 31st to a fabulous crew member who went to some effort to provide me with Taittinger (and better). Perhaps someone who knows better than me will say that Castlenau is the better drop but not in my opinion.


    esselle
    Participant

    I really think it comes down to what you are used to. None of the names cited here are in the top tier by any means, but when you put it into little bottles with plastic screw tops , you are into serious compromise.

    Remember the name only attributes an area, not a quality. If you want fermented sparkling wine, there are any number from outside that designation which are way better. But snob value clearly plays a part.


    seasonedtraveller
    Participant

    I prefer beer.
    Mikeller beers now on SAS are far preferable to fizzy white wine….in my opinion 😉


    icenspice
    Participant

    Serve me a glass (or three) of Freixenet and I am a happy boy.


    AlanOrton1
    Participant

    Pretty sure AA were serving Castlenau NV in J yesterday. Didn’t try it, but they did have a half decent Cabernet Sauvignon from the Margaret River. The other 3 wines on offer were pretty poor, all things considered.


    dutchyankee
    Participant

    Me Thinks some wine ‘snobs’ have entered the fray! 🙂 While I will agree that Taittinger in the lounge is a nice treat, especially the Rose if still being served, it is well known that wine and particularly Champagne change taste rather dramatically at altitude. So while on the ground it seems perfectly fine, in the air it could be mistaken for a Cava or Sekt as its composition changes. That’s why when airlines tout their serving of Dom or Krug as a banner for their exquisite service, I always wonder whether their wine selection process included tasting those fantastic wines in flight as they are nothing to shout about at 35000 feet, and quite frankly a waste of money. I remember there was an uproar on the forum a while back when BA started serving Ayala Brut in Club, yet on board it was very drinkable. Would it be a champagne I would buy for home, no, but in flight it was better than some rather better snob appeal wines. My favourite champagne is Ruinart Blanc de Blancs, and for Rose, Billecart Salmon, but that’s me, however, at altitude, I have no doubt these would taste different. On my Lufthansa flights recently, the Castlenau served was perfectly drinkable. I imagine this is why airlines worth their salt always try their wines at altitude before making a selection. As for CE, I agree with esselle, any champagne served in the 1/4 bottles is not going to be a good indication of the quality of that wine versus in a full sized bottle (wine experts suggest champagne is best from a Magnum), however, when it comes to red wine, it is often said that red wine served in 1/2 bottles or magnums tends to be superior to that served in normal sized bottles, so don’t judge the wine by the container as it just might surprise and delight.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
The cover of the Business Traveller April 2024 edition
The cover of the Business Traveller April 2024 edition
Be up-to-date
Magazine Subscription
To see our latest subscription offers for Business Traveller editions worldwide, click on the Subscribe & Save link below
Polls